Today's Editorial

Today's Editorial - 20 July 2023

France been engulfed by protests again

Source: By The Indian Express

A few months after it witnessed massive protests over pension reforms, France is on the boil again. Over the last four days, protests have swept across France following the death of a young man as a result of excessive use of force by the police.

Cars and public buildings have been set on fire, and clashes have been reported between police and enraged protestors who have taken to the streets to rally against French authorities’ excesses.

As per figures from the French interior ministry, 994 ‘rioters’ were arrested, with 79 police and gendarmes were injured and 2,560 fires on public roads recorded. Since the protests first erupted, well over a thousand people have been arrested with France deploying around 45,000 police personnel on the streets.

Marseilles, the second-largest city of France after Paris, banned protests in a bid to restore peace. According to France24, when reporters asked Prime Minister Elisabeth Born whether the imposition of a state of emergency was a possibility, she said they were “looking at all options, with one priority: restoring order throughout the country.”

Why did the protests erupt?

Large-scale protests were first reported in the suburban Paris and have now spread to a few other cities in France.

These were triggered by the death of 17-year-old Nahel. Nahel was a resident of Nanterre, a suburb to the west of Paris. He was allegedly driving a car without a license around the city when two policemen stopped him.

According to Le Monde, the yellow Mercedes car and its young driver came to the notice of the policemen. They asked the driver to stop the vehicle at a traffic light, but the driver ran the red light. Two passengers were accompanying him.

The car then stopped at the side of a road. According to a video that has been circulating widely after the death of Nahel, at least one of the policemen had their gun aimed at the car while they were talking. After the car drove away from the officials against their orders, a bullet was fired at the boy, killing him, and the car then drove into a roadside pavement. The other passengers fled the scene.

Belonging to a French-Algerian family, Nahel was an only child of a single mother. He was enrolled in a course to become an electrician, as part of a larger programme to upskill and assist young people from disadvantaged areas. His attendance at the college was poor and he played rugby, the report said, adding he did not have a police record.

What has the scale of protests been?

Clashes between the police and protests erupted in and around Nanterre, and the government deployed 2,000 police personnel, AP reported.

Soon however, the protests spread across France, with long-existing undertones of racism in society and the disproportionate use of force by the police at the centre of public anger.

“It’s an explosion of general anger” directed not just at police oppression, but also at economic and racial inequities, Mathieu Rigouste, the author of La Domination Policière, a book examining how French policing practices are rooted in colonialism, told Vox. He added: “In spite of international criticism and local struggles, the French state has continually reinforced its police, prisons, and borders (multiplying weapons, laws, and units specialized in ferocity) as well as judicial impunity over the last 30 years”.

Nahel’s mother has taken part in marches protesting the police action. She said the policemen “saw an Arab face, a little kid, and wanted to take his life” but told France 5 TV that she blamed only the one person who fired the shot, not the police.

Nanterre’s public prosecutor Pascal Prache, in a public statement, said that an autopsy showed that Nahel was killed by a single bullet. A formal investigation of the officer, under the charge of voluntary homicide, has been initiated. “The prosecution considers that the legal conditions for the use of the weapon” by the police officer who fired the shot “are not met”, Prache said.

Rallies have continued despite numerous arrests as well as the generous use of teargas by the police. Over the first two days, the police arrested about 150 people around the country, more than half of them from Paris. Later in the week, many cities witnessed looting and arson. The facade of the Paris aquatic centre where Olympic swimming events will be held in 2024 was damaged.

What has President Macron said?

French President Emmanuel Macron has appealed for calm and termed the death of Nahel as “unforgivable and inexplicable”. He has also said that “Violence against police stations, schools, town halls, against the Republic, is unjustifiable”, in a tweet. He said he would ask social media companies to take down inflammatory messages, “sensitive” footage of rioting and ask for those spreading such messages to be identified.

The government has held meetings on taking steps for calming the situation and police deployment is likely to be increased. Emergency was last imposed following weeks of rioting in France in 2005, when two boys fleeing police, in an attempt to hide, got electrocuted in a power substation. Concerns have been raised over a possible repetition of that time, when thousands were arrested amid protests.

Book A Free Counseling Session