Today's Editorial

Today's Editorial - 07 May 2023

Centre’s stance on the same-sex marriage

Source: By Apurva Vishwanath: The Indian Express

The Supreme Court heard arguments on behalf of the government from Solicitor General Tushar Mehta in the case seeking legal recognition of same sex marriage. While urging the Court to leave the issue to Parliament, Mehta argued that the law cannot be re-drafted again to allow same-sex marriage. Here are six key arguments of the Centre.

  1. Religious definitions of marriage:The Centre’s first submission was that various religions havealways recognised marriage only between a man and a woman. Mehta argued that if a new idea of marriage has to be imagined, then it must be Parliament and not the Court which can create it.

“It is essential to note that marriage, even under the so-called secular Special Marriage Act, 1954, originates in personal law. The said secular enactments were enacted not as a means to create a new social legal institution, but rather as a means to overcome some limitations of religious personal laws,” he said.

  1. ‘Legitimate’ interest of state:Responding to the argument of the petitioners that the state can haveno role in regulating personal relationships, Mehta argued that the state has a ‘legitimate’ interest in regulating marriage. “The right to marry is not absolute and is always subject to the statutory regime provided by the competent legislature,” he argued.

He also cited several aspects of marriage which the state has regulated, such as age of consent to marriageprohibition of bigamy, prescription of prohibited degrees of marriage (which means one can’t marry their lineal ascendants, such as parents, grandparents, etc.), judicial separation, and divorce.

“The state can claim legitimate interest to regulate, when to marry, how many times to marry, whom to marry, how to separate, etc.” the Centre argued.

Mehta told the Court that if the petitioner’s argument were to be accepted, the law on bestiality or incest can also be challenged on the same grounds that the state cannot regulate personal relationships.

The Bench agreed with the Centre that an absolute statement that the state can have no interference in regulating personal relationships might not be correct. CJI DY Chandrachud in an oral observation gave the example of a parent-child relationship that is regulated by the state. “The state requires the child to be educated. The parent cannot say I have absolute control over the child,” he said.

  1. The right to privacy:In thelandmark 2017 decision recognising the right to privacy as a fundamental ri


2521, Hudson Lane Vijay Nagar,
Near GTB Nagar Metro Station, Delhi
Ph.: 97173 80832 | 88605 88805

More Details

Plot No. 48, 1st & 2nd Floor,
Behind Sargam Talkies, Zone 2,
M.P Nagar, Bhopal
Ph.: 75099 75361 | 91798 95361

More Details

111-117, 1st Floor, Veda Building,
Bhawar Kuan Square, Indore
Ph.: 98937 72941 | 0731-497 7441

More Details

A1, 2nd Floor, Mamoor Plaza
Above Airtel Office, 2nd Cross Road, 
5th Block, Koramangala, Bengaluru
Ph.: 76191 66663 | 080-4854 4393

More Details

Ph.: 9289772007

56/4 G. Floor & 32, Old Rajendra Nagar, 
Bada bazaar Road, Near Salwan Public School, 
Gate No.2, Delhi
Ph.: 98112 93743 | 011-4517 0303

More Details

Office No. 42, 2nd Floor, 
OM HEERA PANNA Co-op. Society,
Opp. City International School, Oshiwara,
Jogeshwari (West), Mumbai – 400 102
Ph. 98712 65599 | 882600 2521

More Details

2nd Floor keisamthong Hodam Leirak
Thoudabhabok Machin, 
Imphal West,
Ph.: 96502 45599

More Details

4th Floor, Chinar Heights, 
Near Chinar Colony, Baghat
Dist- Srinagar, J&K- 190005
Ph.: 9871235599

More Details

403-404, Apex Tower,
Lal Kothi, Tonk Road,
Ph.: 82908 00441 | 0141-4052 441

More Details

Above Toyota Showroom,
Exhibition Road, 
Near Gandhi Maidan, Patna
Ph.: 74639 50774 | 0612- 2500 961

More Detail

College More, PTI Building
2nd Floor, Sector - V, Salt Lake
Kolkata, West Bengal 700091
Ph.: 9007709895

More Details

2nd floor, Houses No: 3-6-111/7&6,
Above PUMA Showroom,
Liberty Main Road, Himayatnagar,
Hyderabad – 500 029
Ph. 79960 66663 | 882600 2521

More Details